I know you can see it coming but I have to do it anyway. In MY DAY...talk about grass quality never involved a cow and often involved a glad bag and a boy in Mokena with a Blue Chevy Van. The amount of time we were "on grass" was debatable as no records were kept and the Will County Police Department was anything but computerized. Thanking God for big favors on that one.
So, irony as it is, here I am decades later trying to decide which grass regulation agency is best and does it mater ? Maybe. Probably. Depends.
Earlier today our organic certifier, MOSA, notified us that all our paperwork from last falls organic inspection had been approved as well as our USDA Grass Fed Certification. 2011 was the first year that producers like us could opt to be inspected on both the USDA Organic Standards and USDA Grass Fed Standards at the same time.
It made fantastic sense. Our government using ONE inspector to survey two sets of USDA standards. The whole process went very well and the info we had to submit for the Grass Fed Certification was minimal. Imagine, our government working hard to condense paperwork and costs of such. I was and still am, impressed.
But, of course, I am not satisfied. What did "USDA Grass Fed Certified" really mean ? And what about the American Grassfed Association ? They certify producers as well. I've seen both labels on beef packages in the store. Were the standards the same.?
They are not, although they do have a similar starting place. To date, it is VOLUNTARY to be certified as a Grass Fed Beef Producer. This means there is no law to prevent you from calling your beef Grass Fed even if Miss Udder Delight is fed corn morning, noon and night, This differs widely from the National Organic standards which make it ILLEGAL ( and punishable by fines) if you label your product as Organic when it has not been certified as such. Hmmmm. Wonder if my computer skills are such that I might insert a table into my blog?
Grass Fed Standard Comparisons
USDA Grass Fed | American Grass Fed Association | National Organic Standards | |
Certification Requirements | Voluntary. Anyone can label their beef :Grass Fed” | Voluntary Anyone can label their beef “Grass Fed” | Illegal to use “Organic” label unless you are certified* |
Amount of time on grass | Access to grass and pasture during entire life. May be confined when growing season is over. | Lifetime Forage. No confinement at any time. | 120 days per year must be on pasture |
Nutrient Source | Majority to come from grass | All nutrients to come from forage or pasture | All feed must be certified organic |
Anitibiotic Use | Allowed | Prohibited | Prohibited unless animals life in danger. After use animal must be removed from the farms organic herd |
Hormone Use | Allowed | Prohibited | Prohibited |
Pesticides | Allowed | Prohibited | Prohibited |
Inspection or Audit Fee | None. Certification based on documentation only. | $250 | Varies , Ave is $1000 |
Sometimes a label isn't worth the paper it's printed on.
ReplyDeleteThat is true! When my dad was living he raised everything for the family, well we all helped! Know I have found a farm that I can go look at what I am buying!
ReplyDeleteGreat post, can't wait until our market starts up again so we can support our local farmers.
ReplyDeleteMichelle
You wouldn't believe some of the crazy labels they've tried-out back in the UK. Basically they try to inform folk that products are BRITISH, but the PC brigade don't want to upset foreigners. Hence some very confusing logos.
ReplyDeleteLike Cro says, labelling over here is a mixture of the misleading and the hilarious. My solution? Go to the local butcher and ask him. He knows all the suppliers. It won't work for everyone, but if you can and you trust them, do it.
ReplyDeleteExcellent post and good job with the table! I automatically assume that any government standard is lower than those who are serious about a thing. As has been said, the best way to know what you're eating is to know your farmer.
ReplyDeleteNow what I want to know is that a livestock guardian duck or a herding duck in the third picture? Maybe a border collie duck? You have an innovative farm there ;)
ReplyDeleteYep, I agree know your local farmer.
ReplyDeleteI agree. Know your farmer and "meet the meat". Cheers!
ReplyDeleteI have to admit that the US seems to have a long way to go to meet the Irish guidelines (European). We have such tight guidelines to follow in terms of antibiotics etc. We don't have to certify that our animals are mostly grass fed, cos, they are :) although admittedly they will be fattened for the last couple of months on meal. We have to do a carbon footprint for our beef now too, for those who buy our beef.
ReplyDeleteHaving said that, I detest the way meat/produce can be labelled as Irish just because it has been modified in some way here - we need serious regulation regarding that aspect of it.
ReplyDelete